A method validation plan sets out what a laboratory needs to demonstrate before using a method for routine testing. It defines the intended use, the performance characteristics to evaluate, the acceptance criteria, and the experiments that will provide the evidence. A well-designed plan gives analysts clear instructions and gives the reviewer a basis for deciding whether the method is fit for use.
This guide explains how to develop a method validation plan for ISO/IEC 17025:2017 using a laboratory-developed ICP-MS method for measuring lead in drinking water. The example shows how decisions about the sample matrix, reporting range and use of the results shape the validation study.
1. Define the method’s intended use
Start with the result the laboratory needs to report and the decision it will support. Describe the analyte or property being measured, the sample matrices, the measurement technique, and the concentration range over which results will be reported. Include the required reporting limit and any customer, regulatory or contractual requirements that affect method performance.
For the drinking-water example, first specify whether the method measures dissolved lead or lead following a defined preparation or digestion. Record how samples will be collected or received, preserved and prepared where those steps affect the result. If customers will use the results to assess compliance with a drinking-water limit, record the applicable limit and identify the concentration region where precision, bias and measurement uncertainty matter most.
Record in the plan: the measurand, matrices, method version, reporting units, reporting limit, reporting range and intended use of the results.
2. Decide whether validation or verification is needed
When adopting a standard method within its stated scope, verify that your laboratory can achieve the required performance under its own operating conditions. Validate laboratory-developed and non-standard methods, and standard methods that have been modified or used outside their stated scope, to the extent needed for their intended use.
Review any existing performance data before planning new experiments. Check whether those data cover the proposed matrices, concentrations, equipment and sample preparation. Document what evidence can be used and what gaps the study needs to address.
In this example, the laboratory developed its own ICP-MS procedure for lead in drinking water. The plan therefore needs to show that the complete procedure, including sample preparation and measurement, can meet the performance requirements for the proposed use.
Record in the plan: the type of study, the reason for that decision, the existing evidence and the gaps to address.
3. Select the performance characteristics to evaluate
Choose the performance characteristics that affect the suitability of the results. Each characteristic should answer a question about the method’s intended use.
- Selectivity: Can the method measure lead in the proposed matrices when likely interferences are present?
- Calibration and working range: Does the calibration model support reliable results across the proposed reporting range?
- Limit of quantification: Can the laboratory quantify lead with suitable precision and bias at the required low end?
- Precision: How much do results vary within a run and across relevant routine conditions, such as different days or analysts?
- Bias: How closely do results agree with a suitable reference value or other appropriate reference evidence?
- Robustness: Do small, deliberate changes in selected method conditions materially affect the results?
For the lead method, prioritise the proposed reporting limit and the region near the applicable decision limit. Consider likely interferences across the drinking-water matrices the laboratory intends to accept. Identify which validation data will also support the evaluation of measurement uncertainty and where further evidence may be needed.
Record in the plan: the characteristics selected, why they matter and the concentration levels and matrices each will cover.
4. Set acceptance criteria before running the study
Define a measurable acceptance criterion for each characteristic and document the basis for it. Criteria may come from a regulatory requirement, customer specification, published method, or a laboratory requirement justified by the intended use. State how the results will be calculated and evaluated.
For example, to confirm the proposed reporting limit for lead, define the maximum acceptable imprecision and bias at that concentration, then specify how each will be assessed. Near the applicable drinking-water limit, set performance criteria that support the intended use of the results. Use the actual requirements for your laboratory and jurisdiction when setting numerical limits.
Decide in advance what happens if a criterion is missed. Depending on the cause, the laboratory may need to investigate a deviation, revise the method, raise the reporting limit, or narrow the proposed scope. Record how any follow-up work will be approved.
Record in the plan: the acceptance criterion, its source or rationale, the calculation method and the action if the criterion is missed.
5. Design the validation experiments
Translate each criterion into an experiment that an analyst can follow. Specify the materials, concentration levels, number of independently prepared test portions, number of runs, and which routine conditions will vary. Include the blanks and quality control checks needed to interpret the results.
For the lead example, prepare independent test portions near the proposed reporting limit and near the decision limit, with additional levels as needed to cover the reporting range. Use repeated preparations within a run to assess repeatability. Include multiple runs on different days and vary relevant conditions to assess intermediate precision. Repeated readings of one prepared solution can help assess instrument repeatability, while independently prepared test portions capture variation from the preparation steps as well.
Use a suitable certified reference material where available to assess bias. Matrix spikes can provide complementary evidence about recovery and matrix effects. Record why each material is suitable and which parts of the method it evaluates.
Record in the plan: the experimental design, materials, preparation instructions, conditions to vary, raw data to retain and calculations to perform.
6. Document the plan and assign responsibilities
Combine the decisions into a controlled validation plan. Include the method identifier and version, intended use, study design, acceptance criteria, responsibilities and approval arrangements. A practical way to organise the experiments is to use one row per performance characteristic, with columns for the criterion, materials and levels, experimental design, calculations and responsible person.
Identify who will prepare the materials, run the experiments, review the data and approve the final assessment. Agree how analysts will record deviations and how changes to the study design will be reviewed. In the validation report, compare the results with the planned criteria and record the approved scope and any limitations on routine use.
Use the free Method Validation Planner to draft your study plan and export it to Excel for review.
Conclusion
Start by writing a clear intended-use statement for one method. Then connect each performance characteristic to an acceptance criterion and an experiment that can test it. Review the plan before work begins so the analyst knows what to do and the reviewer knows what evidence will support the decision to approve the method for routine use.
For the wider accreditation context, see Laboratory Quality Management Under ISO/IEC 17025.

